After penalties
- Date
- Kickoff
- UTC
- Venue
- Belson StadiumQueens, NY
- Attendance
- 2,150
Previous Meetings
6 shown
Indy Eleven
vs New York Cosmos
North American Soccer League
2–2
New York Cosmos
vs Indy Eleven
North American Soccer League
3–3
Indy Eleven
vs New York Cosmos
North American Soccer League
2–1
New York Cosmos
vs Indy Eleven
North American Soccer League
1–1
Indy Eleven
vs New York Cosmos
North American Soccer League
3–0
New York Cosmos
vs Indy Eleven
North American Soccer League
3–0