Jun 6, 2026 Steel City FC vs FC Buffalo USL League Two 3–0 Jul 2, 2025 Steel City FC vs FC Buffalo USL League Two 0–0 Jun 25, 2025 FC Buffalo vs Steel City FC USL League Two 1–4 May 21, 2025 Steel City FC vs FC Buffalo USL League Two 2–1 Jun 26, 2022 Pittsburgh Hotspurs vs FC Buffalo National Premier Soccer League 1–2 Jun 10, 2022 FC Buffalo vs Pittsburgh Hotspurs National Premier Soccer League 1–5